Quick Take
Your dishwasher can have two different problems: broken racks or spotty dishes. The four options here fall into two groups. Three are rack assemblies, and one is a rinse aid. The rack assemblies range from USD 186.08 to USD 225.00. The rinse aid is a 32-ounce bottle at USD 28.95. If you are replacing a damaged rack, you need one of the rack assemblies. If your rack is fine but glasses are cloudy, the rinse aid is the direct fix.
Listed Price Comparison
Here is how the listed prices stack up.
| Product | Listed Price | Relative Price Bar |
|---|---|---|
| OEM W10350382 KitchenAid Upper Dish Rack | USD 186.08 | |
| KitchenAid Whirlpool Upper Dish Rack W10056270 | USD 225.00 | |
| Dishwasher Lower Rack Assembly | USD 207.93 | |
| 32oz Jet-Dry Dishwasher Rinse Aid | USD 28.95 |
Decision Matrix
Use this to match your need to the product that fits it.
| Scenario | Best Fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Need a used upper rack for a KitchenAid/Whirlpool dishwasher without choosing the highest-priced one | OEM W10350382 KitchenAid Upper Dish Rack | OEM type, compatible with model FFCD2413US1A, and priced below the other upper rack. |
| Need to match one of several upper-rack part numbers | KitchenAid Whirlpool Upper Dish Rack W10056270 | OEM type with part numbers W10056270, W10728863, and 8561731 in the title. |
| Want a new lower rack rather than a used part | Dishwasher Lower Rack Assembly | New condition with stainless steel and nylon coating details. |
| Want to prevent spots and improve drying | 32oz Jet-Dry Dishwasher Rinse Aid | Most dishwashers, 32 oz, and 315 washes with spot and drying features. |
Product Notes
OEM W10350382 KitchenAid Upper Dish Rack
At USD 186.08, this used OEM upper rack is the lower-priced of the two upper racks in this comparison. It is listed as Whirlpool equipment and compatible with model FFCD2413US1A. Because it is used, it may show light signs of previous use or wear, and the item may vary slightly from the photos. If your dishwasher matches that model, this gives you an OEM part without stepping up to the higher-priced upper rack. It does not include a lower rack or rinse aid.
KitchenAid Whirlpool Upper Dish Rack W10056270
At USD 225.00, this is the highest listed price in the group. It is another used, OEM-style upper rack for Whirlpool dishwashers, and the title includes three part numbers: W10056270, W10728863, and 8561731. Other part numbers tied to it include W10078137, W10312791, and W10727538. If you are matching one of those numbers, this rack may be the right pick. The main trade-off is the price: it costs more than the first upper rack, and the part is still used rather than new.
Dishwasher Lower Rack Assembly
At USD 207.93, this new lower rack assembly sits in the middle of the price range. It lists a matte finish and stainless-steel material, with a 20-inch width. It also has a nylon coating for water and rust resistance and laser-welded construction. If you need a new lower rack rather than a used upper rack, this is the only all-new rack in the group. The trade-off is the price: it costs more than the lower-priced used upper rack, and by itself it does not address spotty glasses.
32oz Jet-Dry Dishwasher Rinse Aid
At USD 28.95, this is the least expensive option here and the only one that targets spots and drying. It is a 32-ounce bottle with 315 washes. The feature set includes 3X better drying, reduced water spots, residue prevention, and glass protection, and it is compatible with most dishwashers. If your dishwasher is working fine but dishes are coming out spotty, this is the low-cost first move. It will not repair a broken or rusted rack, but it can make sense before spending on a rack replacement.
Final Recommendation by Use Case
Here is the short version:
- If your upper rack needs to be replaced and you have model FFCD2413US1A, the OEM W10350382 upper rack is the lower-priced used OEM route.
- If you need one of the listed W10056270, W10728863, or 8561731 numbers, the KitchenAid Whirlpool upper rack is the matching option.
- If you want a new lower rack, the Dishwasher Lower Rack Assembly is the only new rack here.
- If spots and drying are your complaint, try the 32oz Jet-Dry Rinse Aid before buying a replacement rack.
